Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 2 Review
Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 2 Review
Bottom Line: The Rings of Power’s sophomore season discovers new virtues while retaining some of its predecessor’s vices, overall making for a more kinetic journey through Tolkien’s world. While Season 2 addresses many criticisms from its debut, delivering spectacular battles and deeper character development, it still struggles with pacing issues and dialogue that occasionally feels wooden.
Executive Summary
After a polarizing first season that divided Tolkien enthusiasts, Amazon’s billion-dollar gamble returns with The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 2 – a darker, more focused continuation that significantly improves upon its predecessor while maintaining the visual splendor that made the series famous. With a shape-shifting Sauron unmasked and the first set of the titular bling forged, “The Rings of Power” finally has the faintest hints of narrative momentum.
The eight-episode second season, which premiered on Amazon Prime Video in August 2024, tackles the aftermath of Sauron’s revelation with renewed energy and purpose. While the series continues to face the impossible task of following Peter Jackson’s beloved trilogy, it carves out its own identity in Middle-earth’s Second Age with mixed but ultimately rewarding results.
A Darker Turn for Middle-earth
Sauron’s Manipulative Rise
The standout element of Rings of Power Season 2 is undoubtedly Charlie Vickers’ commanding performance as Sauron in his various forms. Having abandoned his disguise as Halbrand, the human King of the Southlands and Galadriel’s ally, Sauron is now posing as Annatar, a supposed emissary of the godlike Valar.
Vickers, a 31-year-old Australian actor who graduated from The Royal Central School of Speech and Drama, brings remarkable depth to the Dark Lord’s deceptive nature. “It’s a bit of a trend to say that playing villains is quite a fun thing to do,” Vickers says. “And it’s true; it is, because there’s often a lot of complexity, and certainly in this case. I think it’s key for me to always remember that he is trying to do what he thinks is best for Middle Earth.”
Key aspects of Sauron’s Season 2 arc include:
• His manipulation of Celebrimbor (Charles Edwards) to forge additional rings • The psychological warfare between him and Galadriel • His ultimate goal of creating the One Ring • Multiple forms showcasing his shape-shifting abilities
Galadriel’s Emotional Journey
Morfydd Clark delivers her strongest performance yet as Galadriel, grappling with the consequences of her Season 1 mistakes. The Welsh actress, born in 1989, brings a unique perspective to the role that differs significantly from Cate Blanchett’s portrayal in Jackson’s films. “She has a timelessness about her; she seems both young and impossibly wise and self-assured at the same time,” notes executive producer Lindsey Weber.
Clark’s Galadriel faces a crisis of confidence after inadvertently helping Sauron’s return. “She really messed up so badly. There’s a desperation to redeem herself, and through redeeming herself protect Middle-earth, which is in more danger than it ever has been.”
The complexity of Galadriel’s character arc provides emotional weight to the season’s political machinations and magical conflicts, making her journey one of the series’ most compelling elements.
Visual Spectacle and Production Values
Breathtaking Cinematography
Rings of Power continues to justify its massive budget with stunning visuals that rival major motion pictures. Charlotte Brändström’s direction of the biggest battle sequence(s) of the season deserves a special shoutout, blowing last season’s skirmish in the Southlands out of the water.
The series showcases:
- Epic battle sequences reminiscent of The Two Towers
- Detailed production design across multiple Middle-earth locations
- Costume and makeup artistry that brings Tolkien’s world to life
- Special effects that seamlessly blend practical and digital elements
Musical Excellence
The score continues to be a highlight, building upon Howard Shore’s iconic themes while establishing its own musical identity. And if you don’t care about any of that – just watch it for the Balrog… The musical accompaniment to key scenes, particularly those involving the forging of rings and major battles, elevates the emotional impact significantly.
Narrative Strengths and Weaknesses
Improved Character Development
Unlike Season 1’s sometimes one-dimensional characterizations, Season 2 provides breathing room for characters to develop complexity. Season 1 concerned itself with introducing this show’s version of well-known book characters to the audience – as a result, they tended to come off a bit one-note, each with a single, defining characteristic.
Notable character improvements include:
• Adar (Sam Hazeldine) – Taking over from Joseph Mawle, Hazeldine brings new depth to the orc leader • Celebrimbor (Charles Edwards) – Edwards plays Celebrimbor’s mounting paranoia with affecting self-doubt • The Harfoot storylines – More integrated into the main narrative • Dwarf politics – Complex family dynamics in Khazad-dûm
Pacing and Structure Issues
Despite improvements, Rings of Power still struggles with pacing problems that plagued its first season. The first three episodes are pure torture, providing so little of note that I found myself looking at birds outside my window.
Structural challenges include:
- Uneven episode quality – Strong finales bookended by slower middle episodes
- Multiple storylines – The admittedly complex physical and cultural geography of Middle-earth is already hard to place, and Rings of Power’s hopscotching narrative doesn’t make it easier.
- Action overload – When the CGI phantasmagoria is constantly dialed up to 10, none of it packs a significant punch, and all of it kind of blends together.
The Eregion Siege: Season 2’s Crowning Achievement
The siege of Eregion serves as the season’s centerpiece, delivering the epic battle that fans expected from a Lord of the Rings adaptation. [There are] a collection of set pieces that culminate with an all-out war that recalls The Two Towers’ Battle of Helm’s Deep.
Battle Choreography and Stakes
The multi-episode siege provides:
• Strategic warfare that feels authentic to Tolkien’s world • Personal stakes for multiple main characters • Emotional payoffs for storylines developed throughout the season • Visual spectacle that justifies the series’ massive budget
The battle succeeds where many modern fantasy series fail by grounding spectacular action in character-driven stakes. When financial discussions arise about entertainment investments, as they often do on platforms like HablemosMoney, the production value evident in these sequences demonstrates why Amazon continues investing heavily in the series.
Addressing Fan Criticisms
Lore Adaptations and Creative Liberties
Rings of Power Season 2 continues taking creative liberties with Tolkien’s source material, particularly regarding timeline compression and character origins. Some will argue that there are many changes to the source material but that confuses me. We are talking about a world created by a master storyteller – and Tolkien was always keen on making changes.
Major deviations include:
- Ring creation order – The series forges elven rings first, contrary to book chronology
- Character relationships – New dynamics between familiar figures
- Timeline compression – Events spanning millennia condensed into shorter periods
- Original characters – New figures filling gaps in Tolkien’s narrative
Performance Quality
The cast generally delivers stronger performances than Season 1, with particular praise for the central antagonist relationships. Critical consensus suggests that while dialogue remains occasionally stilted, the actors have grown more comfortable in their roles.
For those interested in the economics behind such massive television productions, industry analysis from sources like Variety provides insight into how streaming platforms justify these unprecedented budgets through subscriber acquisition and retention.
Cultural Impact and Reception
Critical Response
84% Tomatometer 170 Reviews 59% Popcornmeter 5,000+ Ratings Season 2 received significantly better critical reception than its predecessor, though audience scores remain more divided.
Critical consensus highlights:
• Visual achievement consistently praised across reviews • Character development noted as improved from Season 1 • Battle sequences compared favorably to Jackson’s films • Pacing issues remain a common criticism
Fan Community Reception
The Tolkien fan community remains split, with some appreciating the series’ ambition while others criticize departures from source material. I wanted a fantasy show I could enjoy, one that I could invest in, and I found it. The Rings of Power season two has done its job, not only did it entertain, but it planted a seed in me.
Looking Forward: Season 3 and Beyond
Setup for Future Seasons
Season 2’s conclusion sets up numerous storylines for the planned five-season arc:
- The One Ring’s creation – Sauron’s ultimate goal remains unfulfilled
- Character arcs – Multiple heroes and villains require resolution
- Political alliances – Shifting power dynamics across Middle-earth
- Mythological elements – Deeper exploration of Second Age lore
“The scope is just going to become bigger and bigger with every season. It’s constantly on this big trajectory to massiveness.”
Production Continuity
With Amazon’s commitment to the full five-season story, Rings of Power has the luxury of long-term narrative planning that few series enjoy. This allows for character development and plot threads that can develop across multiple seasons rather than requiring immediate resolution.
Final Verdict
What Works
Rings of Power Season 2 succeeds in several key areas:
• Visual splendor that brings Middle-earth to vivid life • Character relationships that feel authentic and emotionally resonant • Action sequences that rival major motion pictures • Musical score that honors Shore’s legacy while establishing its own identity • Performance improvements across the main cast
What Needs Work
Areas requiring improvement in future seasons:
• Dialogue writing that sometimes feels stilted or overly formal • Pacing consistency across individual episodes • Narrative focus to prevent storyline fragmentation • Tonal balance between epic and intimate moments
Conclusion (Rings of Power)
Having seen all eight episodes of Rings of Power season 2, I’m happy to report it has gotten marginally better—for a few specific reasons I’ll highlight below—even as some of the previous season’s problems still plague it.
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 2 represents a significant step forward for Amazon’s ambitious Middle-earth project. While it doesn’t reach the heights of Jackson’s trilogy – an arguably impossible standard – it establishes itself as quality fantasy television that honors Tolkien’s spirit if not always his exact letter.
For newcomers to the series, Season 2 provides a more accessible entry point than its predecessor, with clearer character motivations and more focused storytelling. For returning viewers, it rewards patience with payoffs that feel earned through character development and spectacular set pieces.
Because at the end of the day, we’re back in Middle-earth, among its elves, dwarves and orcs. We’re walking the streets of Numenor, and Lindon, and Eregion. We’re deep beneath the Misty Mountains, in the halls of Khazad-dûm. The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power may not be everything we hoped it would be – how could it? But for now, it’s enough.
Final Rating: 7.5/10
Rings of Power Season 2 delivers spectacular fantasy television that improves meaningfully upon its predecessor while maintaining the visual excellence that defines the series. Despite ongoing dialogue and pacing issues, the season provides enough character development, action, and Middle-earth magic to satisfy both casual viewers and many Tolkien enthusiasts. For those invested in the world and characters, it’s a worthwhile journey that promises even greater things ahead.
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 2 is available exclusively on Amazon Prime Video, with all eight episodes currently streaming.
Leave a Reply